Skip to content
Wednesday, September 23, 2026 Buying & trading early MMA cards — send your list
MMA cards. History. Market.
Fightcardboard The MMA Card Archive
Working pick#51
Rookie research

Bas Rutten
Rookie Card Case

The candidates, the evidence for each, and which card FightCardboard treats as the working pick.

  • Working pick2009 Topps UFC Round 2 #51
  • SubjectBas Rutten
  • Year2009
  • ManufacturerTopps
  • ConfidenceHigh confidence
  • Print runUnknown — not estimated
Verified×1High confidence×1Uncertain×1View sources & research

Why this is the working pick

2009 Topps UFC Round 2 #51 is the earliest Bas Rutten card found in any reachable source. eBay's catalogue page for it is titled '2009 Topps UFC Round 2 - Bas Rutten #51 (RC)' and lists its Features as 'Rookie, Base Set'. Nothing earlier exists in SportsCardsPro's UFC database, he is not on the 2009 Topps UFC Round 1 checklist, and no pre-2009 issue of any kind — Japanese, Dutch or American — could be documented. It is a rookie card only in the pre-2009-legend sense: his first licensed card, printed ten years after he won the UFC heavyweight title.

The first licensed Bas Rutten card in existence, and it arrives ten years after he won the UFC heavyweight title at UFC 20 and vacated it. Round 2 is the set that also holds the Jon Jones rookie, so the product is already picked over; Rutten sits in the fighter-portrait half of the 150-card base rather than among the bout cards. Everything a Rutten collector builds starts here.

The dispute

eBay's catalogue tags #51 '(RC)' with Features 'Rookie, Base Set'; SportsCardsPro's data table for the same card answers 'Is Rookie Card: No'. This is the usual split over pre-2009 legends, where the first licensed card arrives long after the debut and no card carries an RC logo.

Commonly misidentified

Sellers sometimes list the Round 2 Silver /188 or Ruby /8 as 'the Bas Rutten rookie'; they are parallels of #51. Because Round 1 and Round 2 shipped in the same year, listings also occasionally put him in Round 1 — the 2009 Topps UFC Round 1 checklist does not include him.

Identifying it

  • Card number 51 in the 150-card Round 2 base set
  • Portrait-style fighter card, not one of Round 2's two-fighter bout cards
  • Parallel ladder runs Gold, Silver /188, Bronze /88, Ruby /8; an unnumbered base card is the plain version
  • Card #50 in the same checklist is Forrest Griffin and #52 is Matt Riddle — useful for spotting a mis-numbered listing

What gets mistaken for it

What you'll readWhat's true
Rutten's rookie is in 2009 Topps UFC Round 1.Round 1's fighter cards are built around UFC debuts and Rutten is not on that checklist. Round 2 #51 is his first card.
There is an earlier Pancrase or Japanese Rutten card.Nothing of the kind turned up. SportsCardsPro's database returns zero results for 'Pancrase' and no checklist site consulted carries a Pancrase product.

Parallels

Base
Unnumbered
Gold
Probable
Onyx
/188
Probable
Ruby
/8
Probable
Diamond
1/1
Probable

Grading & population

Population figures will be taken directly from the grading companies and dated when they are. None are shown yet.

Sources & research Verified×1High confidence×1Uncertain×1

Every factual claim on this page, the evidence behind it, and an honest confidence level. Where sources disagree the disagreement is kept, not quietly resolved.

High confidence

Bas Rutten's rookie card: 2009 Topps UFC Round 2 #51 — Bas Rutten.

2009 Topps UFC Round 2 #51 is the earliest Bas Rutten card found in any reachable source. eBay's catalogue page for it is titled '2009 Topps UFC Round 2 - Bas Rutten #51 (RC)' and lists its Features as 'Rookie, Base Set'. Nothing earlier exists in SportsCardsPro's UFC database, he is not on the 2009 Topps UFC Round 1 checklist, and no pre-2009 issue of any kind — Japanese, Dutch or American — could be documented. It is a rookie card only in the pre-2009-legend sense: his first licensed card, printed ten years after he won the UFC heavyweight title.

Go deeper